Official Obituary of

Susan Rene Sheffler

September 28, 1958 ~ March 9, 2024 (age 65) 65 Years Old

Susan Sheffler Obituary

INDIANAPOLIS- Susan Rene Sheffler, 65, of Indianapolis, passed away on March 9th, 2024. Although she could not physically walk due to cerebral palsy, she spiritually walked with her beloved Jesus. Susan was born in Vincennes, Indiana, on September 28th, 1958. She cherished being around family and friends for a variety of activities, special events and occasions and especially liked to celebrate her birthday. Acquaintances and people who knew Susan were blessed by her smile, laughter, and love for life. She enjoyed attending school, going to prom,

reading, painting, coloring, swimming, participating on a bowling team as well as going to concerts, movies, and amusement parks. She took the opportunity to try new things like riding in an airboat and water tubing. She looked forward to family vacations at Dale Hollow Lake that included houseboats, camping, or staying in a cabin and boating. Most of all, Susan loved to attend church to sing hymns, learn more about Jesus and fellowship with other believers.

She was a member of the College Park Baptist Church in Indianapolis. Susan will truly be missed by all, but her memory will continue to bless the lives of everyone who knew her.

She was the beloved daughter of Richard Lee and Shirley Jean (Ball) Sheffler; sister of Donald Sheffler, Teresa (Greg) Holz, Angela (Sam) Wagoner; aunt of Kaitlyn Holz, Sean Wagoner, Kristin Kellar, Andrew and Emily Wagoner, and great aunt of Claire Kellar, and Alexander Wagoner.

Susan was preceded in death by her mother on Dec. 6th, 2023.

Arrangements for Susan include a visitation at 10 a.m. until time of service at noon on Wednesday March 13th, 2024, at Marshall & Erlewein Funeral Home Lewisville Chapel. Brother in-law, Sam Wagoner will officiate. Graveside service will follow at Lewisville Cemetery.

In Lieu of flowers and other sympathy gifts, Memorial Contributions can be made to New Hope of Indiana at 8450 N Payne Rd Suite 300, Indianapolis, IN 46268, or go to

To send flowers to the family or plant a tree in memory of Susan Rene Sheffler, please visit our floral store.

Friends and family have shared their relationship to show their support.
How do you know Susan Rene Sheffler?
We are sorry for your loss.
Help others honor Susan's memory.


March 13, 2024

10:00 AM to 12:00 PM
Marshall & Erlewein- Lewisville Chapel
115 Main Street
Lewisville, Indiana 47352

Funeral Service
March 13, 2024

12:00 PM
Marshall & Erlewein- Lewisville Chapel
115 Main Street
Lewisville, Indiana 47352


New Hope of Indiana
8450 North Payne Road Suite 300, Indianapolis IN 46268


© 2024 Marshall & Erlewein Funeral Home. All Rights Reserved. Funeral Home website by CFS & TA | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Accessibility